Looking for Justice in Church Abuse Case
But It May Never Be Found

Philadelphia Daily News
July 20, 2006

When Some of Philadelphia's alleged victims of pedophile priests couldn't get justice in the courts of criminal law, they turned to the courts of civil law.

But apparently, they may be disappointed there as well.

As Daily News staff writer Michael Hinkelman reported yesterday [see Hinkelman article], the Archdiocese of Philadelphia has asked a federal judge to dismiss a class-action lawsuit filed by 12 people who say they were sexually abused by area priests.

Named in the suit are Cardinals Justin Rigali and Anthony Bevilacqua and the late Cardinal John Krol. They stand accused in the suit of engaging in a conspiracy to cover up the abuses.

The charges are essentially similar to those leveled at the archdiocese last year by a grand jury appointed by District Attorney Lynne Abraham. In that report [see the Philadelphia grand jury report], some 60 priests were named as likely abusers of children, and the grand jury charged the archdiocese with essentially setting up a scheme to avoid prosecution.

"The biggest crime of all is this: it worked," the grand jury said. "The abuser priests, by choosing children as targets and trafficking on their trust, were able to prevent or delay reports of their sexual assaults, to the point where applicable statutes of limitation expired."

As expected, the archdiocese has hotly contested the jury's findings.

Meanwhile, the adults who once, as children, placed their trust in the church are now looking for justice. It's likely they won't find it.

As a matter of law, the archdiocese may be on solid ground in its argument that the allegations are too old to be heard under state regulations. The plaintiffs are using racketeering laws to build their case that the archdiocese engaged in a conspiracy. Those laws, known as RICO, were enacted with an eye toward the mob, and applying them in this situation may be a stretch. New laws are needed, yet Harrisburg has so far refused to act.

So, technically, the archdiocese may never be found guilty. And the archdiocese, to its credit, has set up special programs to assist victims of pedophiles within the clergy.

But you can't say it is innocent. The evidence is so compelling.

Here, in the court of public opinion, the church is the loser.



Any original material on these pages is copyright © 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.